4/20/2008 11:10 AM
Anonymous wrote:
This is one of the best observations on Idea star Singer I have seen on any site. The show has spoiled one acdemic year of the participants who had to leave the show at different stages before the Mega final. Asianet has brought a great carnatic music expert like Dr.Balamurali Krishna as the chief guest in the Mega final and gave the prize to a contestant like Najim who is not one among the best classical singers in the show. On the one hand Asianet claims that their "idea" is to find out the best singer, while on the other hand they say that they are looking for a singer who is a good performer also. Asianet, please define your goal before conducting the contest and make it clear to the participants, judges and viewers. If you are looking for a singer who is a performer or a performer who is a singer also, then bringing people like Dr.Balamurali Krishna will spread a wrong message. If you give at least some importance to "classical music sense" of the contestant then Dr. Balamurali Krishna is an ideal choice. Choosing Najim as the winner instead of Thushar clearly tells us that you have double standards. Reply to this
This is one of the best observations on Idea star Singer I have seen on any site. The show has spoiled one acdemic year of the participants who had to leave the show at different stages before the Mega final. Asianet has brought a great carnatic music expert like Dr.Balamurali Krishna as the chief guest in the Mega final and gave the prize to a contestant like Najim who is not one among the best classical singers in the show. On the one hand Asianet claims that their "idea" is to find out the best singer, while on the other hand they say that they are looking for a singer who is a good performer also. Asianet, please define your goal before conducting the contest and make it clear to the participants, judges and viewers. If you are looking for a singer who is a performer or a performer who is a singer also, then bringing people like Dr.Balamurali Krishna will spread a wrong message. If you give at least some importance to "classical music sense" of the contestant then Dr. Balamurali Krishna is an ideal choice. Choosing Najim as the winner instead of Thushar clearly tells us that you have double standards.
Reply to this