4/8/2008 1:21 AM
salim wrote:
Idea star singer name has to change to Idea sms singer. Among the last 6 singers Arun Gopan was the top in the danger zone appearance. He got once a chance only by reducing the number of elimaters from two to one to save him. This time also he is in the last position but 3rd as per number of sms , but Hisham 3rd position but last as per sms and Hisham got eliminated. Here we see Asianet taking into consideration of sms only.
The same way Amrutha is far better singer than Arun Gopan and Thushar.
If this is the way Idea Star singer 2008 is going to be done, it is better people should not to watch it at all. Reply to this
4/8/2008 1:37 AM
Anonymous wrote:
Come aon Salim and everybody else! Let us not be too passionate about such (non)reality shows!! These shows will always be crowded with interests. The channel's interests, the judges interests (biases and prejudices), the advertisers' interests. And of course the anchor's. In spite of all the negative feelings of so many people towards Renjini, it is very clear that she does have the capacity to influence things and her word too has great value. And surely that's how it should be. We should note that all this is meant for the viewers' entertainment and for the channel (and connected parties) to make business. Nobody is doing charity here.There's no point in raising our blood pressure over these things. In the end, the prize will surely go to somebody who is more closely attached to Asianet, for obvious reasons. 40 lakhs is big money, man!!!!!!!!! Reply to this
4/8/2008 8:46 AM
music lover wrote:
'Nobody is doing charity here'... very correct..But the judges should show some decency and professionalism in their comments. Vodafone thkadhimi 's judges are far far better in that case. Many times i've noticed that , judges are partial to few contestants.Shruthi,tempo, missing words.. etc.. are the common mistakes that every contestant is doing.So, they should reduce the mark equally for everyone.. which is not happening for few contestants. They always score more than 80.. why is like that..? So.. just enjoy the music.. don't ever never take it to heart.. Reply to this
4/8/2008 9:48 AM
anonymous wrote:
kalpana was just being honest. she passed right comments about all the contestents, the negatives as well as positives. leave kalpana alone and comment on the drama that was staged by amrutha as well as durga. it was the worst exit ever. amrutha's mother was a typical example of shameless mother's anxiety for taking her young daughter towards fame by any means. Amrutha... learn some decency and grace from Hisham. the show's name should be changed to ranjini's star singer or sms star singer. Ranjini ...u have a chance in a movie to replace shekkeela... I cannot let my child watch the show bcoz of you. the finals elimination showed how bad an anchor can be. Reply to this
4/8/2008 2:22 PM
riaj wrote:
Noone other than Kalpana would have handled the situation beutifully.She is awesome,no doubt,she did not play with the contestants emotions,leave Kalpana chechi alone Reply to this
4/9/2008 4:44 AM
shanee wrote:
It is a musical programe nta sms program. some body is pushing Arun gopan to final otherwisw He won't. Quarter final round firstly they declared two person wiil be eliminated. But we have seen Vijay eliminated. Arun reached semifinal. I think last 3 or 4 round he was in dangour zone. Amritha or Hisham was more chance to eeach the final than Arun gopan. Blody fool Ranjini Support him More . Reply to this
4/9/2008 5:12 AM
Star Shakeee wrote:
It is a family entertrainer more than a reality show.... which is playing in Kerala.our God's Own Country.because we have a trully and traditionally culture in around our life dressing,eating,etc..... but an TV Anchor she is not in America or Bollywood but in Kerala in Asianet Idea Star Singer programmer how!!!!!! i can't to watch some programme with my family becaouse renjini's dressing...what a dressing in Elivisham round in final Mrs.Renjini is very bloody fool..and toooooooooo craazy by dressing..i am not perfect but she is showing her back side full this seens our father mother and sisters all watching in same time.....please Renjini i would like to tell by advise please make it your dress as a "Malayalippennu"
4/9/2008 7:14 AM
Sanal varma wrote:
I really dis-appointed with the last elimination.I couldn'tunderstand how Arun Gopan has been in.and Amrutha Out ????? Reply to this
4/9/2008 7:23 AM
Sanal varma wrote:
See.. some of the viewer wrote as Amrutha is Best than Arun Gopana and Thushar. But I would like to say onething as a Carnatic Music learned person, Thushar having good knowledge in Carnatic Music even more than Najim.Actually Najim's way of talking like Malayan as over artificial respect. Reply to this
4/10/2008 2:53 AM
Anonymous wrote:
You are right Sanal Varma. I think Thushar and Arun have come off as the most mature guys (Hisham is very much there with them, of course)on this show. More than any of the contestants, and more than the judges or the anchors. I have read a lot of people commenting on Arun and his meaningless smiles on this blog. But I think that's perfectly alright. He is not giving undue importance to the whole thing like every other being on that show. Even Thushar's responses to the judges' comments (good or bad) have been very mature. On the other hand, Najim seems to be going overboard with his vinayam. I have heard him say "Yes sir, thank you sir" even before the judges have opened their mouth!!!!! Vani also had a cool and good demeanour on stage. I do not understand why the judges, the anchor and contestants like Durga, Amrutha and many others before them have to show off their emotions on stage. Occasionally, someone turning emotional, one can understand. But this is more like watching Streejanmam!!!!! Reply to this
Idea star singer name has to change to Idea sms singer. Among the last 6 singers Arun Gopan was the top in the danger zone appearance. He got once a chance only by reducing the number of elimaters from two to one to save him. This time also he is in the last position but 3rd as per number of sms , but Hisham 3rd position but last as per sms and Hisham got eliminated. Here we see Asianet taking into consideration of sms only.
The same way Amrutha is far better singer than Arun Gopan and Thushar.
If this is the way Idea Star singer 2008 is going to be done, it is better people should not to watch it at all.
Reply to this
Come aon Salim and everybody else! Let us not be too passionate about such (non)reality shows!! These shows will always be crowded with interests. The channel's interests, the judges interests (biases and prejudices), the advertisers' interests. And of course the anchor's. In spite of all the negative feelings of so many people towards Renjini, it is very clear that she does have the capacity to influence things and her word too has great value. And surely that's how it should be. We should note that all this is meant for the viewers' entertainment and for the channel (and connected parties) to make business. Nobody is doing charity here.There's no point in raising our blood pressure over these things. In the end, the prize will surely go to somebody who is more closely attached to Asianet, for obvious reasons. 40 lakhs is big money, man!!!!!!!!!
Reply to this
'Nobody is doing charity here'... very correct..But the judges should show some decency and professionalism in their comments. Vodafone thkadhimi 's judges are far far better in that case.
Many times i've noticed that , judges are partial to few contestants.Shruthi,tempo, missing words.. etc.. are the common mistakes that every contestant is doing.So, they should reduce the mark equally for everyone.. which is not happening for few contestants. They always score more than 80.. why is like that..?
So.. just enjoy the music.. don't ever never take it to heart..
Reply to this
kalpana was just being honest. she passed right comments about all the contestents, the negatives as well as positives. leave kalpana alone and comment on the drama that was staged by amrutha as well as durga. it was the worst exit ever. amrutha's mother was a typical example of shameless mother's anxiety for taking her young daughter towards fame by any means. Amrutha... learn some decency and grace from Hisham. the show's name should be changed to ranjini's star singer or sms star singer. Ranjini ...u have a chance in a movie to replace shekkeela... I cannot let my child watch the show bcoz of you. the finals elimination showed how bad an anchor can be.
Reply to this
Noone other than Kalpana would have handled the situation beutifully.She is awesome,no doubt,she did not play with the contestants emotions,leave Kalpana chechi alone
Reply to this
It is a musical programe nta sms program. some body is pushing Arun gopan to final otherwisw He won't. Quarter final round firstly they declared two person wiil be eliminated. But we have seen Vijay eliminated. Arun reached semifinal. I think last 3 or 4 round he was in dangour zone. Amritha or Hisham was more chance to eeach the final than Arun gopan. Blody fool Ranjini Support him More .
Reply to this
It is a family entertrainer more than a reality show.... which is playing in Kerala.our God's Own Country.because we have a trully and traditionally culture in around our life dressing,eating,etc..... but an TV Anchor she is not in America or Bollywood but in Kerala in Asianet Idea Star Singer programmer how!!!!!! i can't to watch some programme with my family becaouse renjini's dressing...what a dressing in Elivisham round in final Mrs.Renjini is very bloody fool..and toooooooooo craazy by dressing..i am not perfect but she is showing her back side full this seens our father mother and sisters all watching in same time.....please Renjini i would like to tell by advise please make it your dress as a "Malayalippennu"
ok..........
Reply to this
I really dis-appointed with the last elimination.I couldn'tunderstand how Arun Gopan has been in.and Amrutha Out ?????
Reply to this
See.. some of the viewer wrote as Amrutha is Best than Arun Gopana and Thushar. But I would like to say onething as a Carnatic Music learned person, Thushar having good knowledge in Carnatic Music even more than Najim.Actually Najim's way of talking like Malayan as over artificial respect.
Reply to this
You are right Sanal Varma.
I think Thushar and Arun have come off as the most mature guys (Hisham is very much there with them, of course)on this show. More than any of the contestants, and more than the judges or the anchors. I have read a lot of people commenting on Arun and his meaningless smiles on this blog. But I think that's perfectly alright. He is not giving undue importance to the whole thing like every other being on that show. Even Thushar's responses to the judges' comments (good or bad) have been very mature. On the other hand, Najim seems to be going overboard with his vinayam. I have heard him say "Yes sir, thank you sir" even before the judges have opened their mouth!!!!! Vani also had a cool and good demeanour on stage. I do not understand why the judges, the anchor and contestants like Durga, Amrutha and many others before them have to show off their emotions on stage. Occasionally, someone turning emotional, one can understand. But this is more like watching Streejanmam!!!!!
Reply to this