3/31/2008 11:49 PM
kuttan wrote:
You are right Apache . Only a suggestion by Didi to Amruta regarding the mistake would have been enough. Instead, she made it a big and sensitive issue and gave unnecessary seriousness. As such she doesn't have aything to comment about the music, only on such out of music stuff she can shine. She utilized that opportunity to the fullest. Reply to this
4/1/2008 12:54 AM
Mani wrote:
Is it really worth commenting. The judges should be asked to read these comments before going further. The way they are promoting Najim is too much to tolerate. They may claim some funny technical point but even lay man can understand. najim inspite of a average performance was given high marks in the thillana round. Asianet can stop the show and giv eth efirst place to Najim now itself. No body will complain as it is their show with their money. Only fools will participate anymore. My heart goes out to Durga and Thushar who are excellent singers. Reply to this
4/1/2008 9:20 AM
praandhan wrote:
i fully agree with Mani.it is now clear that Asianet has already decided the winners through its ever faithfull,partial and loyal trio of judges. Reply to this
4/1/2008 1:35 PM
a.s wrote:
Amrutha is a cry baby....her innocence doesn't seem genuine...she is a good singer and this a competition....her mother looks more tensed than anyone else... Reply to this
4/1/2008 3:04 PMnithin wrote:
Hi a.s. you are right...amrutha is so silly to cry like that...i think theres nothing wrong with didi commenting as thats why shes sitting there in the first place...amrutha should grow up because this is not the audition stage...its the finals so theres no need to cry over small comments.. Reply to this
4/1/2008 3:08 PMseema wrote:
Nithin..you are right...i think amrutha is thinking only of herself and is dumb...a true contestant should be humble and ready to listen to the judges and to not have huge expectations in their performances...instead she crys if anyone says anything that she doesnt like and smiles big when someone says she sang nice... Reply to this
4/1/2008 3:10 PMreeta wrote:
theres no need to cry when a judge says something for your own good...amrutha is too spoilt with too many good comments...thats why when one little thing said by the judges which is not even a cruel comment became negative to her...she couldnt take it Reply to this
4/1/2008 9:37 PM
Balan Anil wrote:
THUSHAR excellent performance. Got 96 (24+24+24+24) Really wonderful. Two time claps in between song. Really amazing. BEST WISHES THUSHAR BALAN ANIL, SINGAPORE Reply to this
4/1/2008 11:27 PM
chandran wrote:
I think Didi should have been more discreet. Amrutha is +2 girl (16~17)and such a reprimand is wholly unwarranted. Didi makes it look like something blasphemous. Come on Didi, we have seen Usha Iyer's( as Didi was known in those days) performance and it was no way comparable to these. What facial expression did she show? I was not able to figure it out. Was it edited out? In that case they should have edited out Usha's comments on that too. I thik Asis net likes these melodramatic emotional scenes. Reply to this
4/3/2008 7:10 AM
priyadarshini wrote:
Always it is found that negative comments make Amrutha feel bad. She is of course very young but i sometimes feel that she is too overconfident. She should be ready to accept the mistakes that's what i feel. I very much agree with the fact that she is spoilt with too many good comments. Reply to this
4/5/2008 5:08 AM
Anonymous wrote:
average performance by najim in thillana round??what are u nuts?!! i guess u didnt understand the complexities of that composition. im not anyone's fan but you all are crazy. the deserving person is getting his due because he's just awesome. Yeah didi is not right all the time probably..but this time she was bang on. and she wasnt rude at all. dont make a fuss out of this. najim, durga, thushar are good. others have been good in patches. thushar was brilliant in the classical round, najim in ghazal round. 2 of the best performances in ISS. period!
4/7/2008 6:59 AM
praandhan wrote:
If you say others wee good in patches i also would strongly and assertively say Najeem was also good only in patches ,He is not at all clear though he may be technically perfect .He is not that pleasant to listen ,just remember music should also have some melody in it. Reply to this
You are right Apache . Only a suggestion by Didi to Amruta regarding the mistake would have been enough. Instead, she made it a big and sensitive issue and gave unnecessary seriousness. As such she doesn't have aything to comment about the music, only on such out of music stuff she can shine. She utilized that opportunity to the fullest.
Reply to this
Is it really worth commenting. The judges should be asked to read these comments before going further. The way they are promoting Najim is too much to tolerate. They may claim some funny technical point but even lay man can understand. najim inspite of a average performance was given high marks in the thillana round. Asianet can stop the show and giv eth efirst place to Najim now itself. No body will complain as it is their show with their money. Only fools will participate anymore. My heart goes out to Durga and Thushar who are excellent singers.
Reply to this
Didi want some other " STUFF " as Uthup is away.
Reply to this
i fully agree with Mani.it is now clear that Asianet has already decided the winners through its ever faithfull,partial and loyal trio of judges.
Reply to this
Amrutha is a cry baby....her innocence doesn't seem genuine...she is a good singer and this a competition....her mother looks more tensed than anyone else...
Reply to this
poor ,soft girl can't really take it
Reply to this
Hi a.s. you are right...amrutha is so silly to cry like that...i think theres nothing wrong with didi commenting as thats why shes sitting there in the first place...amrutha should grow up because this is not the audition stage...its the finals so theres no need to cry over small comments..
Reply to this
Nithin..you are right...i think amrutha is thinking only of herself and is dumb...a true contestant should be humble and ready to listen to the judges and to not have huge expectations in their performances...instead she crys if anyone says anything that she doesnt like and smiles big when someone says she sang nice...
Reply to this
theres no need to cry when a judge says something for your own good...amrutha is too spoilt with too many good comments...thats why when one little thing said by the judges which is not even a cruel comment became negative to her...she couldnt take it
Reply to this
THUSHAR excellent performance. Got 96 (24+24+24+24) Really wonderful. Two time claps in between song. Really amazing. BEST WISHES THUSHAR
BALAN ANIL, SINGAPORE
Reply to this
I think Didi should have been more discreet. Amrutha is +2 girl (16~17)and such a reprimand is wholly unwarranted. Didi makes it look like something blasphemous. Come on Didi, we have seen Usha Iyer's( as Didi was known in those days) performance and it was no way comparable to these. What facial expression did she show? I was not able to figure it out. Was it edited out? In that case they should have edited out Usha's comments on that too. I thik Asis net likes these melodramatic emotional scenes.
Reply to this
Always it is found that negative comments make Amrutha feel bad. She is of course very young but i sometimes feel that she is too overconfident. She should be ready to accept the mistakes that's what i feel. I very much agree with the fact that she is spoilt with too many good comments.
Reply to this
average performance by najim in thillana round??what are u nuts?!!
i guess u didnt understand the complexities of that composition. im not anyone's fan but you all are crazy. the deserving person is getting his due because he's just awesome. Yeah didi is not right all the time probably..but this time she was bang on. and she wasnt rude at all. dont make a fuss out of this. najim, durga, thushar are good. others have been good in patches. thushar was brilliant in the classical round, najim in ghazal round. 2 of the best performances in ISS. period!
- Peace
Reply to this
If you say others wee good in patches i also would strongly and assertively say Najeem was also good only in patches ,He is not at all clear though he may be technically perfect .He is not that pleasant to listen ,just remember music should also have some melody in it.
Reply to this