I feel that all the permanent judges of ISS-2007 should be put on a fair and free trial for all their actions.
Idea Star Singer-2007 has lost its credibility in judgement of contestant's performance long time ago. There are many examples of the results of partiality such as guys like Hisham with no classical music background in the final and guys like Krishnajith Bhanu with good classical music background had to leave the show prematurally. Even judges themselves were laughing at the repetition of "Korrups (Sangathies)" in Hisham's Kachery (Can we call it!)though they gave him marks higher than Najim who is a music student by profession. MG has an argument that Hisham will become an excellent classical music singer when he reaches mid 20s of age. So tell me MG, what will be the future of Krishnajith Bhanu who has similar age as Hisham and is already a good classical music singer? I feel that all the permanent judges of ISS-2007 should be put on a fair and free trial for all their actions.
posted by anonymous
I am surprised to Usha Uthup as a judge classical kacheri and Thillana.. It is like a an English professor evaluating Physics paper!!
Reply to this
MG Sreekumar and Sharath have proved that it really does not matter whether a History, English or Mathematics professor evaluating Physics paper. All of them are giving more or less the same marks! What matters to them is whose paper they are evaluating.
Reply to this
Good one Vinod!!! This was a lady we often invited to Bahrain for shows and I, who had the opportunity to compere a few of her shows, will find it difficult to show respect to her in future!!!
Didi, please do not follow the path of Sthreekuttan and Sarath.
Reply to this
It is very bad and sad to see Abdul Hisham in the final segment. He does not have any talent. He does not know how to pronounce the malayalam words. Krishnajith Bhanu is very much better than Hisham. This is purely partiality, otherwise, he could not have entered the final.
Reply to this
I wonder why people like MG Sreekumar and Usha Uthup are becoming a part of this brutal partiality! Both are quite famous and why do they risk their public image and reputation? I suspect some other black hands behind the whole drama . Or are they both doing this for some one in ASIANET to secure a "permanent" job!
Reply to this
Idea Star singer should be changed to idea selected singers as the singers in the finals Najeem hesham and amrutha arejudges favourites and the judges in selection of finalists and the star singer are not going by any logic.they simply are partial to najeem heaham and amrutha.itis this which has kept out genuine singers like krishnajit,vani jayaram vijay madhavto name a few.
Reply to this
How can a person like Hisham who is a beginner in classical music get marks much higher than Thushar who has the best classical music background of all the contestants. Judges must understand that anyone can find fault with anybody if they wanted it purposefully. That is NOT the true judgement. If the judges have any scale to measure the talents of the singers it should be applicable to all singers equally. Everyone who has reached final have put lot of hard work. So you cannot give marks by just saying that he or she has put hard work. If the contestants have come up to the finals, it is because of your marks ONLY (I don't belive in the sms fraud). You gave marks because yu thought that they did hard work and great performance. If you do not agree, better accept it and quit from the judging panel.
Reply to this
Excellent comment in this forum for ever. I agree with u.
Reply to this