3/21/2008 10:42 PM
Anonymous wrote:
An excellent song by the Great Dakshinamoorthy swami sung by the legendary Daassettan. Mr.Najim, I have a request. Please do not select the songs sung originally by Daassettan. We do not want to listen them thru your husky voice. You may have shruthi, thalam and bhavam. But you do not have "shuddhashabdam". I like your gazal, hariharan and folk songs. Najim,I believe that is your regime. Reply to this
3/21/2008 10:58 PM
Anonymous wrote:
Is Idea Star Singer becoming another "SaRiGaMaPaDaNiSa" by Chirikkutta. You invite you favorite people, give them clues and give them marks and money. If the judges have ever heard the original "Ponveyil manikkachayazhinju veenu" song by Yesudas, they would never give Najim marks more than 70. Reply to this
3/22/2008 12:21 AM
Anonymous wrote:
Why do MG and Sarath promote people like Najim and Hisham? They know very well that these contestants will not pose a real danger to the judges musical career. This is not the case with Thushar, Amrutha and Durga. Reply to this
3/22/2008 2:07 AM
kuttan wrote:
A very high degree of partiality, as evidenced by the last episode.Najim sang well. But the partiality of judges is going on in such a manner that it has become detrimental to the success of other contestants .He ended up getting very high marks even after the very noticeable follwing comments by the judges- M.G.-"The mistake is not justifiable and you are not supposed to do such mistakes", Didi- "Very glaring mistake" Sarath - Justified the mistake by making a comment-"Such mistakes are very common so no need of special mentioning"
The tragedy is that the judges' favourite contestants are enjoying all concessions and justifications for their mistakes while the less favourite contestants have to pay heavily for their mistakes. Being seniors in the field they should encourage all the upcoming singers. Reply to this
3/22/2008 2:25 AM
Anonymous wrote:
Asianet is sot selecting the Ideal Star singer.They have other ideas and agenda, thats why the show is aptly named Idea star singer and not Ideal Star singer.Mannisallayo. Reply to this
3/22/2008 4:10 AM
Anonymous wrote:
Idea star has become a partiality show. This has been proved by yesterday's performance by Najam and the marks given to him. In spite of his mistake in starting the second line and many other mistakes the judges were given his 84marks which is unbelievable. if it were Thushar in his place Mr.MG and Sarath would have insulted him and would be giving him less than 70marks. Please MR.MG and other judges we viewers have an humble request that please do remember that this is a competition and judge all the competitors in a same way otherwise you will lose your popularity and viewers. We viewers are not fools. Reply to this
3/22/2008 10:52 AM
Anonymous wrote:
Idea Star Singer-2007 has lost its credibility in judgement of contestant's performance long time ago. There are many examples of the results of partiality such as guys like Hisham with no classical music background in the final and guys like Krishnajith Bhanu with good classical music background had to leave the show prematurally. Even judges themselves were laughing at the repetition of "Korrups (Sangathies)" in Hisham's Kachery (Can we call it!)though they gave him marks higher than Najim who is a music student by profession. MG has an argument that Hisham will become an excellent classical music singer when he reaches mid 20s of age. So tell me MG, what will be the future of Krishnajith Bhanu who has similar age as Hisham and is already a good classical music singer? I feel that all the permanent judges of ISS-2007 should be put on a fair and free trial for all their actions. Reply to this
3/23/2008 5:47 AMRANJAN wrote:
HISHAM ABDUL WAHAB IS NOT ELIGIBLE TO ENTER THE FINAL. HE IS NOT A GOOD SINGER, WHEN WE COMPARE TO KRISHNAJITH BHANU AND VANI JAYARAM. I AM SURPRISED THAT, HOW THIS GUY HAS ENTERED THE FINAL ! HE IS AN ORDINARY SINGER, BUT, NOT GOOD SINGER. VANI JAYARAM AND KRISHNAJITH BHANU ARE BETTER THAN HISHAM Reply to this
3/23/2008 7:31 AM
najim wrote:
HI VIEWRES.. I M NAJIM ARSHAD..U GUYS WROTE THAT ASIANET HAS SIGNED A CONTRACT WITH ME TO GET THE FLAT.. BUT THATS NOT TRUE..ALLAH GAVE ME NICE VOICE AND WITH HIS BLESSINGS I M TRYING MY BEST TO SING WELLL AND ACCORDING TO THE SONG I M GETTING NICE MARKS..MASHA ALLAH.. PLS GUYS DONT JUST THINK ANYTHING BAD ABOUT ME..I M A GUY WHO PRAYS 5 TIMES A DAY..PLS DONT MISUNDERSTAND Reply to this
An excellent song by the Great Dakshinamoorthy swami sung by the legendary Daassettan. Mr.Najim, I have a request. Please do not select the songs sung originally by Daassettan. We do not want to listen them thru your husky voice. You may have shruthi, thalam and bhavam. But you do not have "shuddhashabdam". I like your gazal, hariharan and folk songs. Najim,I believe that is your regime.
Reply to this
Is Idea Star Singer becoming another "SaRiGaMaPaDaNiSa" by Chirikkutta. You invite you favorite people, give them clues and give them marks and money. If the judges have ever heard the original "Ponveyil manikkachayazhinju veenu" song by Yesudas, they would never give Najim marks more than 70.
Reply to this
Why do MG and Sarath promote people like Najim and Hisham? They know very well that these contestants will not pose a real danger to the judges musical career. This is not the case with Thushar, Amrutha and Durga.
Reply to this
A very high degree of partiality, as evidenced by the last episode.Najim sang well. But the partiality of judges is going on in such a manner that it has become detrimental to the success of other contestants .He ended up getting very high marks even after the very noticeable follwing comments by the judges-
M.G.-"The mistake is not justifiable and you are not supposed to do such mistakes",
Didi- "Very glaring mistake"
Sarath - Justified the mistake by making a comment-"Such mistakes are very common so no need of special mentioning"
The tragedy is that the judges' favourite contestants are enjoying all concessions and justifications for their mistakes while the less favourite contestants have to pay heavily for their mistakes.
Being seniors in the field they should encourage all the upcoming singers.
Reply to this
Asianet is sot selecting the Ideal Star singer.They have other ideas and agenda, thats why the show is aptly named Idea star singer and not Ideal Star singer.Mannisallayo.
Reply to this
Idea star has become a partiality show. This has been proved by yesterday's performance by Najam and the marks given to him. In spite of his mistake in starting the second line and many other mistakes the judges were given his 84marks which is unbelievable. if it were Thushar in his place Mr.MG and Sarath would have insulted him and would be giving him less than 70marks. Please MR.MG and other judges we viewers have an humble request that please do remember that this is a competition and judge all the competitors in a same way otherwise you will lose your popularity and viewers.
We viewers are not fools.
Reply to this
Are they that popular so as to lose popularity?
Reply to this
Idea Star Singer-2007 has lost its credibility in judgement of contestant's performance long time ago. There are many examples of the results of partiality such as guys like Hisham with no classical music background in the final and guys like Krishnajith Bhanu with good classical music background had to leave the show prematurally. Even judges themselves were laughing at the repetition of "Korrups (Sangathies)" in Hisham's Kachery (Can we call it!)though they gave him marks higher than Najim who is a music student by profession. MG has an argument that Hisham will become an excellent classical music singer when he reaches mid 20s of age. So tell me MG, what will be the future of Krishnajith Bhanu who has similar age as Hisham and is already a good classical music singer? I feel that all the permanent judges of ISS-2007 should be put on a fair and free trial for all their actions.
Reply to this
HISHAM ABDUL WAHAB IS NOT ELIGIBLE TO ENTER THE FINAL. HE IS NOT A GOOD SINGER, WHEN WE COMPARE TO KRISHNAJITH BHANU AND VANI JAYARAM. I AM SURPRISED THAT, HOW THIS GUY HAS ENTERED THE FINAL ! HE IS AN ORDINARY SINGER, BUT, NOT GOOD SINGER. VANI JAYARAM AND KRISHNAJITH BHANU ARE BETTER THAN HISHAM
Reply to this
HI VIEWRES..
I M NAJIM ARSHAD..U GUYS WROTE THAT ASIANET HAS SIGNED A CONTRACT WITH ME TO GET THE FLAT..
BUT THATS NOT TRUE..ALLAH GAVE ME NICE VOICE AND WITH HIS BLESSINGS I M TRYING MY BEST TO SING WELLL AND ACCORDING TO THE SONG I M GETTING NICE MARKS..MASHA ALLAH..
PLS GUYS DONT JUST THINK ANYTHING BAD ABOUT ME..I M A GUY WHO PRAYS 5 TIMES A DAY..PLS DONT MISUNDERSTAND
Reply to this